A letter that says VA "proposes" to lower your rating is not a reduction yet. You have time to respond. What you do now can decide how this ends.
The short version
- A proposal is not a reduction. It opens a window of time for you to act.
- Put the deadline on your calendar the day the letter comes.
- Find out exactly what VA says got better, and what evidence VA used.
- Get your own records. Then fill the gaps with evidence.
- Check your dates. Some ratings are protected after 10 or 20 years.
- Get help now, before VA makes a final decision.
Read the verb
Read the letter again. This time, look at the verb.
VA proposes to reduce your evaluation, or rating. Proposes. That does not mean VA has reduced it. It does not mean VA is lowering it on the first of the month.
That one word is the difference between a crisis and a deadline. Most veterans who call me about these letters have already skipped past it. They went straight to the number at the bottom of the page.
A proposal is not a reduction. It opens a window of time. What you do inside that window decides how this ends.
What VA has to do before anything changes
VA does not just cut the amount it deposits. Before a reduction takes effect, VA has to:
- Propose it in writing.
- Tell you what evidence it is relying on.
- Give you time to respond, send evidence, and ask for a hearing.
Each of these is a chance to act. And each one gets wasted the same way. The letter goes in a drawer, because opening it again is unpleasant.
So do these five things, in this order.
Step 1: Put the deadline on your calendar the day the letter arrives
The letter states your response period. Find it. Write the date on a calendar you actually look at. Set a reminder well before the deadline, not on it.
That window runs from the date on the letter. It does not start the day the mail got sorted. It does not start the day you opened it.
Maybe you moved. Maybe your mail was forwarded. Maybe the letter sat at a relative's house for two weeks. If so, you have already lost part of your window. You need to move faster, not slower.
This is the most common way a case that could be defended turns into a smaller check. Not a bad argument. A missed date.
Step 2: Find out exactly what VA says improved
Go through the letter with a pen. Answer three questions in writing.
- Which condition is at issue? Sometimes it is one of several. Then the rest of your file is not in play.
- What evidence is VA relying on? It might be a recent exam, a treatment note, or a review of records. The letter is supposed to tell you. That evidence is the entire case against you.
- What exactly does VA say got better? Not just "the veteran has improved." Which finding? Which measurement? Which symptom?
You cannot fight a conclusion. But you can fight specific things, like these:
- A measurement.
- A date.
- A missing record.
- An examiner who wrote down full function without testing for it. Function means what your body can do.
Step 3: Get your own records before you write a word
Ask for the exam report VA relied on. Also ask for your recent treatment records. Then read them the way a rater would, not the way a patient does. A rater is the VA worker who decides your claim.
Look for these problems:
- Findings written down that were never actually tested or measured.
- A snapshot from an unusually good day. The report says nothing about flare-ups, bad weeks, or what you cannot do the rest of the month.
- Treatment records from the same time that describe you very differently.
- Anything the examiner did not have. This could be private treatment, a specialist, a surgery, medicine changes, or an emergency visit.
- Symptoms blamed on something else, or a condition you never raised.
Then fill the gaps. All of these are evidence:
- Recent treatment notes.
- A statement from your treating provider. It should talk about what you can and cannot do, not just your diagnosis.
- Statements from a spouse, an adult child, or a coworker who sees the bad days.
- Your own statement. Say how often it happens, how long it lasts, and what you can no longer do.
Step 4: Know which protections may already apply to you
Don't assume this is a fight about medicine. Check the calendar first. Some ratings are protected just by the passing of time.
Twenty years
This rule is 38 CFR 3.951(b). Say a disability has been rated at or above a level, with no break, for 20 or more years. VA cannot reduce it below that level, except on a showing of fraud.
The same protection applies to a permanent total rating for pension purposes held for 20 or more years.
The 20 years runs from the effective date of the original rating to the effective date of the proposed reduction. The effective date is the date a rating or change takes effect.
Ten years
This rule is 38 CFR 3.957. Service connection means VA agrees your condition is linked to your service. If service connection has been in effect for 10 or more years, VA will not sever, or cut off, that link. There are two exceptions:
- A showing of fraud.
- Military records show the person did not have the required service or discharge.
The law behind this rule is 38 U.S.C. 1159.
A rewritten rating schedule is not, by itself, a reason
The rating schedule is the set of rules VA uses to rate conditions. VA sometimes rewrites it. Under 38 CFR 3.951(a), a change to the rating schedule is not a reason to reduce your rating. The exception is if medical evidence shows your disability actually improved.
What you can do: Pull your effective dates. Compare them to those two clocks. It takes ten minutes. And once in a while, it ends the whole discussion.
Step 5: Get help, and get it now, not later
A proposal comes with a set response period and a right to a hearing. Both are worth more before VA makes a decision than any argument made after.
Bring these papers:
- The proposal letter.
- The exam report.
- Your recent treatment records.
- Your rating history with effective dates.
A VA-accredited attorney can tell you in one reading what you are arguing about. It may be the medicine, the procedure, or the calendar. Those are three different cases.
Four things not to do while the window is open
- Do not ignore it and hope it was a mistake. Nothing in this system fixes itself out of embarrassment.
- Do not stop treatment. The time between the proposal and the decision is exactly when your records need to be up to date. Staying away creates the silence VA is describing.
- Do not call and make it up as you go. Answer in writing, with documents attached. That way, what you said is in the file the way you meant it.
- Do not exaggerate. Credibility means people believe you. It is the one thing you cannot rebuild. An honest account of a bad month is stronger than a puffed-up account of a bad year.
If VA reduces your rating anyway
A final decision is not the end of the road. You usually have one year from the date of that decision to choose one of these:
- Supplemental Claim on VA Form 20-0995. You send new and relevant evidence.
- Higher-Level Review on VA Form 20-0996. A senior reviewer looks at it, with no new evidence.
- Board Appeal on VA Form 10182. A Veterans Law Judge reviews your case.
Pick the lane that matches the problem:
- If the record was thin, that is a Supplemental Claim.
- If the record was fine but VA read it wrong, that is a Higher-Level Review.
I have opened one of these letters myself. The panic is real, and it is temporary. The deadline is the only part of this that will not wait for you.
The Jacks Law Group represents veterans nationwide and worldwide from offices in Henderson and Las Vegas, Nevada. David R. Jacks, Jr. is a VA-accredited attorney and a 100% permanently and totally disabled U.S. Army veteran. If you want help with a claim or an appeal, call to set up a consultation.
Disclaimer: This blog is general information only. It is not legal advice for your case. Reading it does not, by itself, make us your lawyers. Every VA claim depends on its own facts. Rates, rating rules, and program rules change over time. For advice about your own case, talk with a VA-accredited attorney.
