CALL NOW TO SCHEDULE A CONSULTATION 702-834-6300
CALL NOW TO SCHEDULE A CONSULTATION

Blog

How to Read Your VA Rating Decision, Line by Line

Posted by David R. Jacks, Jr., Esq. | Nov 19, 2026

The percent is the least useful part of your VA rating decision. The pages around it tell you what VA decided, why, and how much time you have to respond.

The short version

  • Find the date on the letter first. It starts a one-year clock.
  • Check that every condition you claimed is on the "what we decided" list.
  • Read the evidence list to see what VA looked at, and what is missing.
  • Find the one sentence in "reasons and bases" that carries the decision.
  • Check each effective date. It controls your back pay.
  • Check your combined rating and your dependents.

Most veterans read a rating decision the same way. They find the percent, feel something about it, and put the envelope in a drawer.

The percent is the least useful thing in that packet. Everything you need to decide what to do next is in the pages around it:

  • What VA decided.
  • What VA looked at.
  • Why VA landed where it did.
  • When your money starts.
  • What date your clock started.

Here is how to read it, line by line.

Start at the end: the date on the letter

Before you read anything else, find the date printed on the decision. Write it on the outside of the envelope.

That date starts a one-year clock. Within one year, you can file one of these:

  • A Supplemental Claim on VA Form 20-0995.
  • A Higher-Level Review on VA Form 20-0996.
  • A Board Appeal on VA Form 10182.

Contested claims have a 60-day deadline at the Board instead. A contested claim is one where more than one person is claiming the same benefit.

If the year passes and you have not filed anything, the decision becomes final. Then a simple disagreement turns into a much harder problem.

There is a second clock much further down the road. Under 38 U.S.C. 7266(a), a notice of appeal to the Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims is due within 120 days after notice of the Board's decision is issued. That is not today's problem. The one-year date is.

"What we decided" is a list, and lists have gaps

The first main section is a list of issues. Each issue has a result. Compare it to your own list of what you claimed.

Check three things, in this order:

  • Is every condition you claimed on the list? Conditions get dropped, put off, or quietly folded into another issue. A claim VA never decided is a different problem from a claim VA denied. It gets fixed a different way.
  • Is anything marked "deferred"? Deferred means VA put it off for later. A deferred issue is still alive and still pending. Do not appeal it as if it were a denial.
  • What happened to each condition, one at a time? One packet can grant one thing and deny two others. Veterans often see the grant and miss the denials under it.

Say VA granted a condition but rated it lower than you expected. Notice what you did get: service connection for that condition. Service connection means VA agrees your condition is linked to your military service.

Arguing later that the rating is too low is a different fight. It is a much easier fight than proving service connection from scratch.

The evidence list shows what VA actually looked at

Somewhere in the packet is a list of the evidence VA says it considered. Most people skim this part. Read it with a pen.

You are looking for what is missing. Ask yourself:

  • Is VA's records request to your private orthopedist (bone doctor) there? Did anything come back from it?
  • Is the C&P exam you went to listed? C&P stands for Compensation and Pension. It is the medical exam VA uses to check your claim.
  • Are your service treatment records listed, or only your VA records?
  • Did the buddy statement your platoon sergeant wrote make it into the file? A buddy statement is a written statement from someone who is not a doctor.

Sometimes the list shows that VA asked a private provider for records and never got them. Then VA denied you for lack of evidence. If so, you have found your appeal.

That is not a medical disagreement. It is a record that never arrived. It is the most fixable thing in the whole process.

Reasons and bases is the roadmap

This is the section written out in sentences. It is the most valuable page in the packet. Somewhere in it is one sentence that carries the whole decision.

If VA denied service connection, that sentence almost always says one of three things:

  • There is no current diagnosis.
  • There is no event or injury in service.
  • There is no medical link between the two.

If your rating came in lower than you hoped, the sentence says the evidence does not show a certain level of severity. It will usually name the specific findings VA was looking for and did not see.

Find that sentence and underline it. Then match it to the right lane, meaning the right type of review:

  • The missing piece is evidence you can go get. That is a Supplemental Claim, VA Form 20-0995. You must send new and relevant evidence. VA's duty to assist applies, which means VA must help you get evidence. These claims have averaged around 59 days, against a goal of 125 days.
  • The evidence was already in the file, and VA misread it. That is a Higher-Level Review, VA Form 20-0996. A senior reviewer takes a fresh look at the same record. No new evidence is allowed. You can ask for an informal conference, which is a talk with the reviewer.
  • You want a Veterans Law Judge to look at it. That is a Board Appeal, VA Form 10182. It has three dockets, or tracks. The two tracks that allow new evidence usually take longer.

The three Board tracks are:

  • Direct Review: No new evidence, and a 365-day goal.
  • Evidence Submission: You can send evidence within 90 days.
  • Hearing: You get a hearing.

Picking the wrong lane is the most common avoidable mistake I see. The reasons and bases section tells you which lane you are in.

The effective date line

Every granted issue has an effective date. The effective date is the date VA starts paying from. Your back pay comes from that date. Check each one separately.

Ask yourself when you first put VA on notice. Did you file an Intent to File on VA Form 21-0966? Then your effective date should usually reflect that. It should not be the date you finished the application months later.

The dollars here are not small. A veteran at 70% with no dependents gets $1,808.45 a month. Six months of effective date, on that one rating, is more than $10,000. It is worth an hour of your time.

The combined rating, and why the math looks wrong

If VA rated more than one condition, you will have a combined rating. It will not equal the sum of the parts.

That is not a mistake. VA figures combined ratings under 38 CFR 4.25. It does not just add them up. It works on the part of you that is left after each disability is applied. Then it rounds to the nearest ten. So two ratings that look like they should total 80 can combine to well below that.

While you are here, check your dependents. They only change your pay at 30% and above. At that point, they matter. At 30%:

  • A veteran alone gets $552.47 a month.
  • With a spouse, the amount is $617.47.
  • With a spouse and one child, it is $666.47.

If VA does not have your family right, the combined rating can be perfect and the check can still be wrong.

What to do in the first week

  1. Scan the whole packet, front to back. Save it somewhere that is not a drawer.
  2. Write the one-year date on a calendar you actually look at.
  3. Underline the sentence in the reasons and bases that carries the decision.
  4. List the evidence that should have been in the evidence list but was not.
  5. Ask for your claims file.

Why ask for the claims file? The decision letter is a summary written by the person who decided against you. The file is the record.

I read a lot of decisions that look terrible on page one. Then, four pages in, they turn out to be a records problem with a simple fix. Read the whole thing before you decide how you feel about it.

The Jacks Law Group represents veterans nationwide and worldwide from offices in Henderson and Las Vegas, Nevada. David R. Jacks, Jr. is a VA-accredited attorney. He is also a 100% permanently and totally disabled U.S. Army veteran. If you want help with a claim or an appeal, call to schedule a consultation.

Disclaimer: This blog is general information only. It is not legal advice. Reading it does not, by itself, make us your lawyers. Every VA claim depends on its own facts. Rates, rating rules, and program rules change over time. For advice about your own situation, talk with a VA-accredited attorney.

About the Author

David R. Jacks, Jr., Esq.
David R. Jacks, Jr., Esq.

David Jacks is a seasoned attorney and founder of The Jacks Law Group, PLLC, in Las Vegas and Henderson, Nevada. Born and raised in Las Vegas, he served as an Animal Care Specialist in the U.S. Army before transitioning to a career in law. He earned his BA in Political Science from UNLV and his JD from Arizona Summit Law School. David’s practice focuses on Veterans' Claims And Appeals. He is recognized for his professional excellence and has received numerous awards. David is actively involved in the legal community and various professional associations.

Our Offices

Henderson (client office): 1057 Whitney Ranch Drive, Suite 350, Henderson, NV 89014. Hours: Mon-Fri 9:00 a.m.-5:00 p.m. PT. Phone: 702-834-6300. Fax: 702-982-7171. Email: [email protected]. We represent veterans in Henderson, Las Vegas, North Las Vegas, Clark County, and worldwide - you do not have to visit an office.

Meet Our Founder

Attorney David R. Jacks, Jr. is a VA-accredited attorney and 100% P&T disabled U.S. Army veteran. Learn more about our founder.

Menu